For investment firms, private banks and financial advisers
When a client says the investment was unsuitable, show the assessment as it was on the day.
Markets fall, and some clients then remember a different conversation. What settles it is the suitability assessment and the statement on suitability you gave before the transaction. What weakens it is any doubt that those documents are the ones you had at the time, rather than ones tidied up once the loss was known.
- When it is tested
- A complaint after a loss, taken to your national financial ombudsman; a supervisor’s inspection of your advice files; a claim against your professional liability cover; a court.
- What you will be asked for
- The information you obtained on the client’s knowledge, experience, financial situation and objectives (MiFID II, Article 25(2)), and the statement on suitability given before the transaction (Article 25(6)). Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/565, Article 72(1), describes how records are to be kept: so that corrections, and the contents before them, can be easily ascertained, and so that records cannot otherwise be manipulated or altered. Where Article 16(7) applies, the recordings of telephone conversations and electronic communications, kept for five years, or up to seven where the supervisor asks.
- What goes wrong today
- The assessment lives in an advice tool, a CRM or a document store, and any of them can be edited by someone with the right access. Their audit trail is that system’s own word. A risk profile updated innocently after a loss looks exactly like one changed to win the complaint.
- What changes
- Each assessment and each statement is sealed the moment it is produced, by your advice software or by hand. A correction becomes a new sealed version, so the original stays provable beside it. In a dispute you hand over the document and its receipt, and the other side checks both themselves. The client’s data never reaches us: only a salted fingerprint does. A call recording stays in your archive; its fingerprint is sealed as the call ends, so the file you produce years later can be shown to be the one recorded.
Sealing shows that a record existed unchanged from a given moment; whether your record-keeping meets Article 72 is yours to judge. The MiFID II record template lists the fields to keep and the article each one answers.
Try it in two minutes
- Choose a suitability report or a risk-profile questionnaire of your own. It is read in your browser and never uploaded.
- Seal it on Seal a file. A free sandbox key is issued on the page; only a salted fingerprint reaches the log.
- Make a copy, change one character in it, and check both against the receipt at Check. The copy fails; the original passes.
From your own advice software it is one API call per document. Integrate · The case for your software vendor